Tired of toxic political conversations? How can we make your political discussions more constructive and positive? Pastor Joe shares practical tips on how to engage in constructive political discussions without falling into hostility. Learn how to approach others with humility, curiosity, and love, keeping faith at the center of it all. Let’s transform our political dialogues and build bridges instead of walls and discover how you can make a difference, one conversation at a time.

New to Life Center? Click here

Gave your life to Jesus? Click here

Sunday, July 7, 2024
Pastor Joe Wittwer
Thou Shalt Not be a Jerk!
How to have constructive conversations in a toxic time.

Romans 14

Introduction:

I got off social media in 2016. Can anyone guess why? Yeah—the political cycle got so crazy, and Facebook posts turned toxic, angry and ugly. Every time I got on, I just got frustrated and upset, and I knew if I got sucked in, I’d be a jerk…so I got off. I still have my Facebook and Instagram accounts, but I rarely post and never scroll. And I don’t remember a single person ever reading one of those rants and being changed. “I see the light!”

Thou shalt not be a jerk! It’s the 11th commandment. And it’s the title of Eugene Cho’s excellent book on engaging in politics as a Christian. Sadly, Christians have not been immune to our toxic political environment, and have often been angry, nasty, judgmental and partisan. Today we’re going to talk about how to have constructive conversations about politics, and avoid being a jerk.

Last weekend, Pastor Michael kicked off our series, “Jesus and Politics.” It’s an election year, and we want to help you think Christianly about politics and how to navigate this season. Michael did a great job reminding us that we are all about the Kingdom of God. Jesus is our king and that shapes every part of our lives, including our politics. If you are a follower of Jesus, Please let your faith inform your politics, not your politics inform your faith. It’s Jesus first—always.

I asked Michael if I could talk about how to have good conversations about politics because I hear so many people having bad ones—including me! How many of you have had a political conversation with someone that went south—ended badly? Did you walk away thinking, “What a jerk!” Or did the other person think that about you? How can we disagree without being disagreeable? It’s ok to disagree…but not to be disagreeable. Most importantly, how can we understand the other person and actually learn something? That’s what we want to talk about.

How many of you know who you are voting for President? How many of you know that you’re right? I love being right—and of course, I am. I tell people who disagree with me, “You have the right to be wrong.” My wife says that my love language is being right!

Have you ever been around a know-it-all? Have you ever been a know-it-all? Me too. It’s hard to learn when you know-it-all. And we’re called to be learners—that’s what a disciple is—a learner. If we’re going to bridge the gaps between us, we’re going to have to become learners who are genuinely curious about the other person.

So I’m starting with personal confession. Political conversations with others who see it differently are hard for me. I like to be right. I think I know more than I do. I am often not curious, but can be judgmental and dismissive—“Oh, you’re one of those!” Cancelled! So I end up gravitating to people who I know agree with me and avoiding people who don’t. That’s me. Pray for me. Anyone else?

How can we change and have conversations about politics that are actually constructive and helpful? It’s important because the only way we’ll change the toxic climate is one honest, humble, constructive conversation at a time. Here we go.

1. Start with you.

This comes straight from Jesus in Matthew 7:1-5 (Pg. 832)

“Do not judge, or you too will be judged. 2 For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.

3 “Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye? 4 How can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ when all the time there is a plank in your own eye? 5 You hypocrite, first take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye.

This is one of the funniest things Jesus said. Imagine me trying to take a speck of dust out of your eye when I’ve got this plank sticking out of mine! Crazy! So Jesus says, “First, take the plank out of your own eye.” Start with you. Before you try to fix anyone else, start with you.

So before we go charging into the political fray to change others and convert them to our point of view, start with you. After all, the only person you can change is you. How many married people have made this discovery the hard way?

A. Check your heart.

I’ve already told you that I tend to be a know-it-all who’s always right. For all of us like that…NEWS FLASH: You don’t know as much as you think you do!

You don’t know as much as you think about the issues and candidates. Tough issues are hotly debated precisely because they’re complex and difficult to solve. Today’s politics specialize in sound-bites. We often base our opinions on one-sided headlines and quotable sound-bites rather than complex, nuanced arguments.

More importantly, you don’t know as much as you think about the person who disagrees with you. You may not know their story, their experiences, their values and concerns, all of which have shaped their opinions.

ILL: Monica Guzman, in her excellent book, I Never Thought of it That Way, tells about her conflict with her parents. She is a young Seattle liberal who voted for Clinton and Biden; her parents are first-generation Mexican immigrants who voted for Trump. She could not understand how they could vote for Trump, and their conversations often devolved into arguments. Then one day, her parents shared with her some parts of their story she’d never heard before, and they shared how those experiences shaped their values that led them to vote for Trump. A light went on for Monica. She called it an INTOIT moment—I never thought of it that way. She said that if she had her parents’ experience, she would have their values and would have voted for Trump. While she still doesn’t agree with them, she understands them. The change: she learned what she didn’t know.

Start with you. Check your heart. You don’t know as much as you think.

How many of you think you are a better than average driver? Top 50%? In one study, 93% believed themselves to be better than average—in the top 50%. At least 43% are dead wrong!

ILL: Brant Hansen, in his book, The Truth About Us, tells the story of researchers in the 1970s who stood outside a department store and asked women to check out samples of four different pantyhose brands. They asked, “Which one do you like the most?” The subjects’ opinions varied widely from each other, but they were very decisive. “This one is clearly better,” or “This one is much softer,” or “This one is such higher quality.” As it turns out, they were all the exact same pantyhose. But what happened next is the really amazing thing. When told that the samples were, in fact, all the same, the subjects doubled down! They felt a need to defend their stated opinions, even in the face of the indisputable evidence. They tried to argue that the researchers were wrong.

It’s hard to admit you’re wrong. So let’s practice! Turn to your neighbor and say, “I’m wrong.” How many spouses just heard that for the first time ever?

Start with you. You don’t know as much as you think. You’re wrong more than you know. So…

Be humble and curious, not judgmental. If you know everything and you’re always right, you’ll be judgmental—everyone else is stupid and wrong. But if you don’t know everything and you know you can be wrong, you’ll be humble and curious. Being humble and curious is essential to learning anything and having constructive conversations. And the goal of good political conversations is not to win an argument and convert the person to your view—that’s highly unlikely. The only person you can change is you. The goal is to learn something and to understand the other person.

ILL: Braver Angels is a national grass roots organization whose goal is to “Bring Americans together to bridge the partisan divide and strengthen our democratic republic.” (Their web address is at the bottom of your outline.) Braver Angels says, The goal of political conversations is to learn about the other person’s position and find accurate disagreement—not to persuade them to change their mind.

Start with you. The only person you can change is you. Be a disciple, a learner. Be curious not judgmental. If you are going to engage in political conversations, do it as a learner, not a know it all. Be genuinely curious about others. Each person is unique, unique, unique—a mystery to be explored and understood. Let’s start trying to understand each other and stop judging and cancelling those who disagree with us. It begins with humility and curiosity.

Start with you. Check your heart. Then…

Check your sources.

Our beliefs form over our lifetimes as a result of our lived experiences, our relationships, our families of origin, our education and other factors. They tend to be reinforced and shaped by current sources such as our news feeds, social media, and exchanges with friends.

Another NEWS FLASH: Not all sources are equally true and helpful. You don’t believe everything you see posted on social media, do you? Of course not. Nor everything you watch on TV or hear on podcasts. I’ve been saying this for years now: Know the difference between news, opinion and entertainment.

      • News: A good news program will attempt to be objective and stick to reporting facts—they’re not always successful, but that’s the goal of news—objectivity. Here are the facts, what happened.
      • Opinion: An opinion piece is just that: opinion, not fact. It’s one person’s perspective on the news. It may be helpful depending upon how informed it is. You can be ignorant and still have an opinion. So here’s another important reminder: Not all opinions are created equal. Some are informed, some are not. Some are based on facts, some are not.
      • Entertainment. Many talk shows, podcasts and broadcasts are entertainment. Their aim is not educating, but entertaining; and they’re driven by the bottom line: ratings and money. The more outrageous you are, the higher your ratings and the more money you rake in. Did you know that it’s been shown that the best way to get likes and shares on your social media posts is to be angry and outrageous? Same for these entertainment programs.

Why did I take time for this? Because too many people are listening to entertainment and thinking it’s news. It’s not. Not all sources are equally true and helpful. Check your sources.

If you enjoy getting your news from an openly biased source, then take some time to check out their competitors. Proverbs encourages us to get both sides.

Proverbs 18:17 In a lawsuit the first to speak seems right, until someone comes forward and cross-examines.

Proverbs 18:17 There are two sides to every story. The first one to speak sounds true until you hear the other side and they set the record straight. (The Passion Translation)

When someone is making a case, they present the evidence that supports their view, and ignores the evidence that challenges their view. Everyone does this—I do, and you too. This is why we need to get the other side of the story. Always. Don’t be afraid to do some fact checking.

ILL: Recently, someone told me about something President Biden had done. “Really?” I said. It made me mad. Then I decided to do some fact checking, and I discovered that what I had been told was inaccurate and wrong. It had a grain of truth, but important facts had been left out, which changed the story completely.

Get both sides. Do some fact checking. And then remember that most political issues are complex and won’t be solved by simple answers and sound bites. Complex problems require complex and nuanced solutions. But those don’t sell well, because we want certainty, not ambiguity. We gravitate to the political extremes—right or left—because they are pedaling certainty. Don’t buy it!

Start with you. Check your heart: be a learner who is humble and curious. And check your sources: get both sides, check your facts, beware of certainty.

2. Love your neighbor.

What’s the Great Commandment? The most important of all God’s commands? Love God with all you’ve got: heart, soul, mind and strength. And…love your neighbor as yourself. This is a non-negotiable for all Jesus-followers. You have to love your neighbor. And who is your neighbor? When Jesus was asked that, He told the story of the Good Samaritan, who loved someone who was his enemy, someone of a different race and religion. Your neighbor is whoever is standing before you right now, no matter their race, religion or politics. Love your neighbor—right or left, Democrat or Republican.

Can Christians have different political opinions? Of course! In Romans 14 (Pg. 976), the apostle Paul tells Christians how to handle “disputable matters” or “matters of opinion.” He deals with two: diet and days of worship. Both of these were differences between Jewish and Gentile Christians in the Roman Church. And while we’re not wrestling with those same debates, much of what Paul says can be applied to conversations about political opinions as well.

Romans 14:3 The one who eats everything must not treat with contempt the one who does not, and the one who does not eat everything must not judge the one who does, for God has accepted them.

Paul addressed both sides—meat eaters and vegans, right and left, Republicans and Democrats—and says we must not treat each other with contempt or judge each other. Instead of judging and cancelling, what do we do? We act in love.

Romans 14:15 If your brother or sister is distressed because of what you eat, you are no longer acting in love. Do not by your eating destroy someone for whom Christ died.

There is the guiding principle. We act in love. We love our neighbor. We remember that this person who is spouting stuff I disagree with is loved by God, accepted by God, and is someone for whom Christ died! This person is of infinite value to God, so I need to treat them with the same value and love. Jesus didn’t die for my pet issue, for my political views. He died for the brother or sister in front of me, even those with whom I disagree. So I can’t judge them, cancel them, treat them with contempt. I must love them.

Romans 14:19 Let us therefore make every effort to do what leads to peace and to mutual edification.

There’s the end result: peace and mutual edification. We get along and we build each other up. We learn from each other, understand each other, value each other. Notice that Christians can have differing opinions about lots of things. I’ve heard people say, “I don’t see how you can be a Christian and vote Democrat (or Republican or for so-and-so).” Christians can and do have different political opinions. We can talk about them without rancor because we love and value each other above our opinions. We are united by one thing: our love for Jesus and His love for us, not by any set of political opinions.

So how can we have a political conversation that is constructive, that builds us and the other person up and we leave in peace—maybe not agreeing about everything, but still loving each other? Here are some suggestions.

Start with positive attributions. If you start with negative attributions—people who believe this are stupid—your conversation is doomed before you start. People have reasons for what they believe. Our job is to discover those reasons and understand them. We don’t have to agree, but we want to understand. We can’t demonize others and assume the worst about them.

ILL: In 2018, I was privileged to go on the Congressional Civil Rights Pilgrimage with Cathy McMorris Rodgers and several African American leaders from Spokane. I was able to have good conversations with congressmen and women from both sides of the aisle. Several of them commented that we all want the same things—good education for our kids, good health care, safe communities, good jobs, economic security, and so on—but we have different views on how best to achieve those. The best solutions won’t come from one side or the other, but from both contributing their best ideas. And for that to happen, we have to work together, and we can’t demonize each other.

Start with positive attributions: you’re smart and I want to learn from you.

Set out to learn something, not prove something. Often, when the subject turns to politics, people get emotional and combative. They want to make their point and convince you they’re right. It never works. Remember: the only person you can change is you. Make it your goal to learn something about the other person, not win an argument.

ILL: One of my favorite stories in Monica Guzman’s book is the “Melting Mountains” story. In 2016, 74% of King County voted for Hillary Clinton. Monica decided to find their exact opposite—a county that voted 74% for Trump—and see if they could have a conversation. So 20 Seattleites made the trek to Sherman County, Oregon, population 3,020, to meet with 16 locals. They engaged in conversation as a group and then in pairs. The room buzzed—not with arguments, but learning. One of the farmers shared his concern about the Waters of the United States rule. The Seattleites all thought, “What in the world is that?” It turns out, the rule defines what bodies of water fall under federal regulation, and it’s a big deal for farmers, and it’s why some of them voted for Trump. Monica said lights went on for her and her Seattle friends. “These are not right-wing hicks from the sticks, but intelligent and reasonable men and women who are dealing with realities we’ve never faced!” They learned something.

Set out to learn something.

Be genuinely curious about and interested in the other person. This is a person God created—they are His masterpiece, a unique one-of-a-kind work of art. This is a person God loves, a person for whom Christ died, a person of infinite worth. People aren’t puzzles to be solved, but mysteries to be explored. Turn to your neighbor and say, “You’re a mystery.” And “You’re a masterpiece!”

This is why when I meet people one of my first questions is, “Tell me your story.” The shortest distance between two people is a story. Know their story and you’re on your way to understanding them.

Learning peoples’ stories also goes a long way to explaining their political views. If you are in a political conversation and are baffled by someone’s position, back up and ask them to tell their story.

Be genuinely curious about others. And that leads to:

Ask good questions. Curious people ask more questions and make less pronouncements. Live life in the form of a question. Did you know that Jesus used questions to provoke and stir faith in people’s lives? Tom Hughes, in his book, Curious: The Unexpected Power of a Question-led Life, wrote:

“Throughout the four Gospels of Jesus, Jesus is asked 183 questions. Of those 183 questions, how many do you think he answered directly? Four. He responds to the other 179 questions with a question, a parable, or a cryptic remark that leaves those gathered with even more questions…Jesus himself asks an astounding 307 questions in the Gospels.”

Tom’s point: Jesus used questions to get people to think, to explore, to believe. Good questions may do more to stir people’s thinking than all your pronouncements of certainty!

What are good questions? Open ended questions that give people opportunities to explain. Here are some examples.

      • Tell me your story.
      • Help me understand what you believe.
      • What brought you to those conclusions?
      • What am I missing?
      • How did you come to believe X?
      • What are your concerns? Hopes?
      • What do you mean by…?
      • Tell me about an issue you care about. Tell me everything I need to know to fully understand your take on the issue.

(Manuscript on our website.) Ask good questions—you’ll not only learn something but so will they!

Share your opinion honestly and humbly. A good conversation is bilateral—you both talk, you both listen, you both learn. I’m not suggesting that you just listen and never share your opinion—both of you should be able to share honestly and humbly.

By humbly, I mean avoid using absolutes: “This is the way it is.” Instead, use I-statements. “I see it like this.” It shares your view while acknowledging there may be other ways to see it.

Speaking of that, you don’t have to have an opinion on everything. It’s ok to say, “I don’t know.” Let’s practice. Turn to your neighbor and say, “I don’t know.” See…that wasn’t hard. I say that a lot these days. If I don’t know the facts, or when I don’t have enough good information to have an informed opinion, I say, “I don’t know.”

Also, if the other person doesn’t seem curious about you and your point of view, you might want to ask permission to share it. “Would you like to hear my perspective on that?” If they say yes, but then interrupt or talk over you, stop and remind them that you asked if they wanted to hear your perspective and because they said yes, you’re trying to share it with them.

If they clearly aren’t interested and just want to argue, then it’s time to move on. Change the subject or find another conversation. But avoid heated arguments over politics—they can be harmful. You can win the argument and lose the person. How many of you have broken relationships with someone because they just want to fight about politics?

Share your opinion honestly and humbly. One more:

Keep the main thing the main thing. What’s the main thing? Jesus. I’d much rather talk about Jesus than politics. No one will be saved and go to heaven based on who they vote for this fall. No one will experience Life to full—abundant life now and eternal life forever—because they vote for Trump or Biden, but only because they follow Jesus.

Our hope is not in either political party or any political candidate. Our hope is in Jesus. So let’s talk about Him! Christians: if we win a political argument, but lose the person for Jesus, we’ve lost the plot! We’ve missed the main thing. The big question isn’t who you vote for, but do you follow Jesus? Let’s ask that question. Let’s keep the main thing the main thing.

Life Center
Life Center
Jesus + Politics: How to not be a Jerk
Loading
/